Print

Everyday Sourdough Sandwich Bread

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

5 from 8 reviews

I haven’t bought sandwich bread in over 7 years because of this sourdough bread recipe!  It’s such a staple in my house because even though I make sourdough bread (artisan loaves) everyday, my kids really prefer sourdough sandwich bread.  They love it so much, they even eat the crust!

Ingredients

Scale
  • 265 water
  • 100g active sourdough starter
  • 1 Tbsp honey
  • 500g AP flour
  • 7 g salt
  • 56g stick butter (½ stick)

Instructions

Step 1 – Feed your sourdough starter

  • Feed your sourdough starter and use when it’s at peak (when it can no longer rise and starter to crater a little)
  • You can use your normal sourdough starter or
  • You can use a sweet stiff sourdough starter to make sure the sandwich bread isn’t sour

Step 2 – Mixing your ingredients together

  • To a stand mixer, mix all of the ingredients in the order you see me listing it above
  • Mix until the sourdough dough is stretchy and smooth
  • You want it to pull away from the sides of the mixing bowl and be smooth and elastic
  • Takes around 10 minutes on level 4 (mixer might be dancing)
  • IF it’s been a while and the dough is not coming off the the sides or bottom,
  • stop the mixer and scrape the sides and bottom with your plastic bench scraper, continue mixing
  • You can also pause and give the mixer a rest if needed
  • Continue mixing until you have a windowpane
  • Don’t stress if not completely coming off the sides –it’s okay!

Step 3 –  Bulk Fermentation/Room temp proof/1st Rise

  • Take the dough out with your plastic bench scraper
  • Shape the dough into a taut ball
  • Put it in a bowl, cover
  • Room temp proof for 2 hrs

Step 4 – Cold proof/2nd Rise

  • Cold proof in your fridge overnight (roughly 8-10hrs at 36F)

Step 5 – Shaping

Option 1 – normal 1 log

  • Shape the sourdough dough by rolling the dough flat into a rectangle
  • Then simply roll it up into a log
  • Pinch the seam a little
  • Place the log into a parchment lined or buttered loaf pan
  • Cover lightly so it doesn’t dry out

Option 2 – cute 3 logs

  • Divide the sourdough dough into 3 equal parts
  • Roll the dough flat into a rectangle, they should be the width of the pan
  • Roll each dough into a short logs
  • Pinch the seam a little
  • Place the short logs into a parchment lined or buttered loaf pan
  • Cover lightly so it doesn’t dry out

Step 6 – Room temp proof/Final Proofing

  • Final proof at room temp for 2-4 hours, or until *almost* doubled

Step 7 – Baking

  • Bake at 375F for 45 min, or until golden on top
  • Wait at least 30 min before slicing

Notes

Swapping ingredients?

  • swap butter for coconut oil

Crust too dull or pale?

  • Egg wash the dough before baking

Conversions

  • 1 stick of butter = 113g

Crust too hard and looks burnt?

  • Brush the top of the bread with milk to soften the top

Too sour?

  • use a sweet stiff sourdough starter instead

Save this page so you don’t lose it

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.